Commonplace books are not so uncommon. Virginia Woolf kept one. So did
Samuel Johnson. W. H. Auden published his, as did the poet J. D.
McClatchy. E. M. Forster's was issued after his death. The novelist
David Markson wrote terse and enveloping novels that resembled
commonplace books; they were bird's nests of facts threaded with the
author's own subtle interjections. For fans of the genre, many prize
examples have come from lesser-known figures such as Geoffrey Madan
and Samuel Rogers, both English, who issued commonplace books that are
notably generous and witty and illuminating. These have become cult
items. The literary critic Christopher Ricks said about Rogers that,
although he may not have been a kind man, "he was very good at hearing
what was said."
-- Dwight Garner. Garner's Quotations: A Modern
Miscellany [preface] (2020).
I am no special fan of most books of quotations. Bartlett's Familiar
Quotations, The Yale Book of Quotations, and The New Penguin
Dictionary of Modern Quotations, to name three dependable reference
books, are invaluable, for sure, as repositories of literary and
verbal history. (Countless other books of quotations aren't reliable
at all, and the less said about quotation sites on the Internet the
better.) But even the best contain a good deal of dead weight. They
lean, sometimes necessarily, on canned and overused thought and,
grievously, are skewed to the upbeat. So many of the lines they
contain seem to vie to be stitched onto throw pillows or ladled, like
soup, over the credulous soul. "Almost all poetry is a failure,"
Charles Bukowski contended, "because it sounds like somebody saying,
Look, I have written a poem." The same is true of quotations and
aphorisms. So many have a taxidermied air, as if they were
self-consciously aimed at posterity.
-- Dwight Garner. Garner's Quotations: A Modern
Miscellany [preface] (2020).